Beyond Rankings: Why Influence, Not Just SEO, Wins the Digital Game

Don’t Panic… But Also, Maybe Panic a Little

Somewhere in the vast, mostly inhospitable reaches of the digital marketing universe, another small business has just been fleeced for $20,000. The victim? A tradie, a local retailer, a startup—pick one. The crime? A marketing agency promised them the moon (or at least page one of Google). The reality? Four website visits a month. No sales. No ROI. Just existential dread and a big, fat invoice.

If this scenario sounds distressingly familiar, congratulations! You’ve just stumbled upon one of the greatest cosmic mysteries of the marketing world: Why do small businesses keep falling for the same SEO and digital marketing traps?

The short answer? Because they’re looking for certainty in a universe that doesn’t have any.

The long answer? Well, grab your towel, because we’re about to take a Hitchhiker’s Guide to SEO Disasters—and, more importantly, how to escape them.

The Great SEO Conundrum: Why Small Businesses Struggle With Digital Marketing

Many marketing agencies, in their eagerness to win clients, often oversimplify SEO and digital marketing, selling it as a certainty rather than an evolving process. They’ll tell you SEO is the answer. Or Google Ads will fix everything. Or AI will write all your content, optimise your site, and personally tuck you into bed at night.

The problem? Marketing isn’t a vending machine.

You don’t insert money and instantly get customers out the other end. Marketing—real, effective marketing—is an experiment. And most agencies aren’t brave enough to admit that.

According to a survey by HubSpot, 75% of businesses say their marketing strategies aren’t effective, yet they continue to invest in cookie-cutter SEO packages that promise results but fail to deliver. Meanwhile, Google’s search algorithm updates over 500 times a year, meaning no strategy can afford to be static.

Small businesses, on the other hand, are in survival mode. They don’t have the luxury of waiting 6-12 months for their SEO to “kick in.” They need leads now. So when someone offers them a neatly packaged, guaranteed result, they take it.

And that’s how they end up burning through $20K on SEO with nothing to show for it.

Search Engine Influence (SEI): The Alternative to Digital Snake Oil

If SEO is often misunderstood as a shortcut to instant success, Search Engine Influence (SEI) is the wise old mechanic who teaches you how to drive properly and build a reliable car.

What’s the Difference?

• SEO (Search Engine Optimisation) is about optimising your website to help Google understand and rank it appropriately.
• SEI (Search Engine Influence) is about building trust, relevance, and influence so that Google (and AI-driven search) recognises your site as the best answer.

According to Rand Fishkin, founder of Moz and SparkToro, “SEO isn’t about gaming the system anymore; it’s about being the best result.” That’s the core of SEI—helping businesses become the most relevant, trusted source of information in their niche.

Leigh Baker, an advocate for sustainable business growth, reinforces this point: "Short-term SEO tactics won’t sustain you in the long run. Influence and trust will." (Read more on Leigh Baker’s blog).

SEI doesn’t just care about rankings—it cares about relevance, trust, and influence. It asks, “Are you actually valuable to your audience?” If the answer is no, no amount of surface-level SEO efforts will be enough.

AI, The New Digital Snake Oil Salesman

Remember when marketing agencies used to promise “guaranteed page-one rankings”? Well, they’ve rebranded. Now they’re selling “AI-powered instant leads” and “AI-written content that ranks in minutes”.

The pitch is irresistible:

• “AI will generate all your content for you!”
• “You don’t need a strategist—just let AI optimise your ads!”
• “SEO is dead—trust the algorithm!”

Spoiler alert: AI is not your saviour. It’s a tool. And just like any tool, if you don’t know how to use it properly, you’re going to end up hammering your own thumb.

A study by Gartner predicts that by 2026, 80% of marketers who rely solely on AI-generated content will see a decline in engagement rates due to lack of originality and authenticity. AI can assist, but it cannot replace human insight and strategic thinking.

Here’s the truth: AI doesn’t know your business. It doesn’t understand your customers. It doesn’t know your competitors, your market, or what makes you different.

And most importantly? AI is trained on the internet that Google organises. If your business doesn’t influence search engines, you won’t influence AI either.

So How Do Businesses Stop This From Happening?

If you’re a business owner reading this, wondering if you’re about to be the next $20K horror story, here’s the uncomfortable truth: marketing isn’t something you buy. It’s something you build.

That means:

• Knowing what problem you’re solving before you hire anyone.
• Asking the right questions (and walking away if the answers are vague).
• Expecting transparency, not guarantees—real success takes time.
• Treating your marketing like an experiment, not a one-off transaction.

If you’re working with an agency, make sure:

• You understand what you’re paying for—SEO isn’t the same as ads, content, or PR.
• You demand real metrics, not vanity stats—rankings don’t matter if they don’t drive sales.
• You get a strategy that fits your business, not just a generic service package.
• You hold your agency accountable—they should explain everything in plain language. 

Time to Step Up

This problem isn’t going away. AI is muddying the waters, marketing is getting more complicated, and small businesses are still being sold dreams instead of real strategies.

As Neil Patel says, “Real marketing takes work. If someone tells you otherwise, run.”

Small businesses need to demand more transparency.
Agencies need to stop selling certainty where there is none.
And the entire industry needs to stop pretending marketing is easy.

Because until that happens?
We’re going to keep seeing more $20K disasters.

  Author: Ian Hopkinson 

    Digital Madman, Founder of Terminology and Mad Scientist Digital

    Socials: Instagram / / LinkedIn 

    Websites: Terminology / / Mad Scientist / / Hopkinson Creative